Jurisprudencia Administrativa y Constitucional (Tribunal Supremo de Justicia y Cortes de lo Contencioso Administrativo): Segundo Semestre de 2023
| Date | 01 July 2023 |
| Author |
"
Kphqtocek„p"Lwtkurtwfgpekcn"
Jurisprudencia Administrativa y Constitucional
(Tribunal Supremo de Justicia y
Cortes de lo Contencioso Administrativo):
Segundo Semestre de 2023
Ugngeek„p."tgeqrkncek„p"{"pqvcu"
rqt"Oct{"Tcoqu"Hgtpƒpfg¦"
Abogado
Secretaria de Redacción de la Revista
UWOCTKQ"
K0" QTFGPCOKGPVQ"EQPUVKVWEKQPCN"["HWPEKQPCN"FGN"GUVCFQ""
30"El Ordenamiento jurídico0"C0"Rtkpekrkqu"Hwpfcogpvcngu"fgn"Guvcfq0"c0"Eqpukfgtcekqpgu"uqdtg"gn"
Ukuvgoc"Fgoqetƒvkeq"tgrtgugpvcvkxq"{" rctvkekrcvkxq"eqphqtog"c"nc"Eqpuvkvwek„p" fg"3;;;0"D0"Uqdtg"
nc"eqpvtqxgtukc"uqdtg"gn"Gugswkdq"{"ncu"rqnvkecu"iwdgtpcogpvcngu"
KK0"" FGTGEJQU"["ICTCPVëCU"EQPUVKVWEKQPCNGU"
30"Garantías Constitucionales0"C0" Nc"ictcpvc"fg" ceeguq"c"nc" lwuvkekc fg"kpvgtfiu"rtqegucn0"
40"Derechos Individuales0"C0"Nkdgtvcf" fg"Vtƒpukvq."Tfiikogp" eqphqtog"c"nc" Eqpxgpek„p"Cogtkec/
pc"fg" Fgtgejqu" Jwocpqu0" 50" Derechos Políticos0" C0" Nqu" Tghgtgpfqu" Eqpuwnvkxqu" eqoq" Kpuvtw/
ogpvq"fg"Fgoqetcekc" Rctvkekrcvkxc"D0"Fgtgejq" c"cuqekctug"gp" rctvkfqu"rqnvkequ"{" tfiikogp"fg" nqu"
rctvkfqu0""
KKK0"" NC"CEVKXKFCF"CFOKPKUVTCVKXC""
30"Actos Administrativos; Vicios de fondo: Falso supuesto."
KX0"" NC"LWTKUFKEEKïP"EQPVGPEKQUQ"CFOKPKUVTCVKXC"
30"Recurso de Nulidad. Notificación0"Cambio de criterio0"40"Recurso contra la Abstención o nega-
tiva de la Administración: Procedencia.
X0"" NC"LWUVKEKC"EQPUVKVWEKQPCN"
30"Competencia de la Sala Constitucional para ejercer el control previo de la constitucionalidad
de los Referendos Consultivos0"40"Recurso de Interpretación: Improponible. Normas de carácter
Sublegal0"50 Revisión Constitucional." C0" Kortqrqpkdng0" D0"Cfokukdknkfcf0" 60" Acción de Amparo
Constitucional."C"0Eqorgvgpekc0"D0"Cfokukdknkfcf
XK0" GN"QTFGPCOKGPVQ"VTKDWVCTKQ"FGN"GUVCFQ""
30"Impuestos Municipales.
TGXKUVC"FG"FGTGEJQ"RòDNKEQ"Ṗ"3971398"Î"4245"
"
546"
K0" QTFGPCOKGPVQ"EQPUVKVWEKQPCN"["HWPEKQPCN"FGN"GUVCFQ""
30 El Ordenamiento jurídico
C0" Principios Fundamentales del Estado
c0 Consideraciones sobre el Sistema Democrático representativo y partici-
pativo conforme a la Constitución de 1999
VUL/UE"*368;+"" 53/32/4245"
Rqpgpekc"Eqplwpvc"
Ecuq Coqtquq."rtgukfgpvg"fgn" Eqpuglq" Pcekqpcn"Gngevqtcn." eqp" gn"
qdlgvq" fg" swg" guvg"„ticpq" lwtkufkeekqpcn" ÐÈug" rtqpwpekg" cegtec" fg" nc"
eqpuvkvwekqpcnkfcf" fg" ncu" rtgiwpvcu" swg" ug" hqtownctƒp" gp" gn" Tghgtgpfq"
Eqpuwnvkxq"gp"fghgpuc" fg" nc" Iwc{cpc" Gugswkdc." swg" ug" tgcnk¦ctƒ" gn" vtgu"
*5+"fg"fkekgodtg"fg"42450"
Xgtkhkecfc"nc"eqorgvgpekc"fg"guvc"Ucnc" Eqpuvkvwekqpcn."eqp"gn"qdlgvq"fg"tguqnxgt" gn"cuwp/
vq"swg"csw"jc"ukfq"uqogvkfq"cn"lw¦icokgpvq"eqpuvkvwekqpcn"swg"tgcnk¦c"guvg"„ticpq"fg"lwuvkekc."
eqpukfgtc"pgeguctkq" ukipkhkect" swg" gn"Rtgƒodwnq" fg" nc" Eqpuvkvwek„p"fg" nc" Tgr¿dnkec" Dqnkxc/
tkcpc"fg"Xgpg¦wgnc." swg"kpvgitc"eqp" hwgt¦c"pqtocvkxc"cn"Vgzvq"Hwpfcogpvcn."fg"cewgtfq"eqp"
nc"fqevtkpc" fg" nc" ugpvgpekc" fgn" 3;" fg"gpgtq" fg" 3;;;." ecuq ÐReferendo ConsultivoÑ." fkevcfc"
rqt"nc"cpvkiwc" Eqtvg"Uwrtgoc"fg" Lwuvkekc"gp"Ucnc" Rqnvkeq/Cfokpkuvtcvkxc"{" swg"jc"ukfq" ocp/
vgpkfc"rqt"guvc" Ucnc."cenctc"swg" nc"kpvgpek„p" fgn"eqpuvkvw{gpvg"fg" 3;;;."ukiwkgpfq" gn"ocpfcvq"
rqrwnct"swg" ng" hwg" eqphgtkfq" rqt" ncu"ekwfcfcpcu"{" nqu" ekwfcfcpqu" gp" tghgtfipfwo" fgn" 47"fg "
cdtkn"fg"3;;;."hwg" tghwpfct"nc"Tgr¿dnkec" rctc"guvcdngegt"wpc" uqekgfcf"fgoqetƒvkec."rctvkekrc/
vkxc"{"rtqvci„pkec." eqp"nq" ewcn"{c" pq"u„nq"gu" gn"Guvcfq" gn"swg"jc"fg"cfqrvct" {"uqogvgtug" c"nc"
hqtoc"{"rtkpekrkqu"fg"nc"fgoqetcekc."ukpq"vcodkfip"nc"uqekgfcf"*kpvgitcfc"rqt" ncu"ekwfcfcpcu"{"
nqu" ekwfcfcpqu" xgpg¦qncpqu+." swkgp" fgdg" fgugorg‚ct" wp" tqn" fgekukxq" {" tgurqpucdng" gp" nc"
eqpfweek„p"fg"nqu"fgttqvgtqu"fg"nc"Pcek„p0"
Rctvkgpfq"fg"vcn"rqukek„p."fg"cewgtfq"eqp" gn"ctvewnq"4" fg"nc"Eqpuvkvwek„p."nc"Pcek„p"xg/
pg¦qncpc" ug"eqpuvkvw{g"gp" wp" Guvcfq" fgoqetƒvkeq" {" uqekcn" fg" Fgtgejq" {" fg" Lwuvkekc." ew{qu"
xcnqtgu"uwrgtkqtgu"uqp"nc"xkfc." nc"nkdgtvcf." nc"lwuvkekc."nc"kiwcnfcf."nc" uqnkfctkfcf."nc" fgoqetc/
ekc."nc" tgurqpucdknkfcf" uqekcn." nc"fivkec." gn" rnwtcnkuoq"rqnvkeq" {" nc" rtggokpgpekc"fg" nqu" fgtg/
ejqu"jwocpqu="ukgpfq" nc"ictcpvc"{" tgurgvq"fg"fkejqu" rquvwncfqu"czkqn„ikequ" qdnkicek„p"kttg/
pwpekcdng"fg"vqfqu"nqu"„ticpqu"swg"glgtegp"gn"Rqfgt"R¿dnkeq."{"tgurqpucdknkfcf"eqorctvkfc"fg"
fiuvqu"eqp" nc" vqvcnkfcf"fg" ncu" rgtuqpcu"swg" jcdkvcp" q"tgukfgp" gp" gn"vgttkvqtkq" fg"nc" Tgr¿dnkec."
ugi¿p"nq" guvcdngekfq." gpvtg"qvtqu."gp" nqu" ctvewnqu"77."84." 92." 9;.":2." :5." :6."324." 349." 353."
354."357." 363."388." 38:."3:4." 3:6."3:7." 426."427."433." 475."492." 49;."4;7." 4;;"{" 548"fg"nc"
Pqtoc"Hwpfcogpvcn0"
Nq"cpvgtkqt."gpewgpvtc" uw"hwpfcogpvq" gp"gn" ctvewnq"7."ugi¿p" gn"ewcn" nc"uqdgtcpc" tgukfg"
kpvtcpuhgtkdngogpvg" gp" gn" rwgdnq." swkgp" nc" glgteg" fktgevcogpvg" *fgoqetcekc" fktgevc+" gp" nc"
hqtoc"rtgxkuvc"gp"nc"rtqrkc"Eqpuvkvwek„p"*xgt"ctvewnqu"84" {"uu0+"{"gp"nc"ng{."g"kpfktgevcogpvg"/
ogfkcpvg"gn" uwhtcikq/" rqt" nqu" „ticpqu" swg"glgtegp" gn" Rqfgt" R¿dnkeq." {" gp"gn" ctvewnq" 8." swg"
eqpucitc"fg"ocpgtc" fghkpkvkxc"eqoq" hqtoc"fg"iqdkgtpq"fg"nc" Tgr¿dnkec"{"fg"ncu"fgoƒu"gpvk/
fcfgu"rqnvkeq/vgttkvqtkcngu"nc"fgoqetcekc"rctvkekrcvkxc"{"gngevkxc."fguegpvtcnk¦cfc."cnvgtpcvkxc."
tgurqpucdng."rnwtcnkuvc"{"fg" ocpfcvqu"tgxqecdngu."eqp" nq"swg"pq"gu" rqukdng"pkpiwpc"qticpk¦c/
ek„p"fgn"Guvcfq"swg"pkgiwg"q"kpqdugtxg"vcn"eqphkiwtcek„p"kpuvkvwekqpcn0"
Fg"eqphqtokfcf"eqp"nq"cpvgtkqt."nc"Eqpuvkvwek„p"fg"3;;;."tgkortguc"gp"Icegvc"Qhkekcn"ṗ"
70675."Gzvtcqtfkpctkc."fgn" 46"fg"oct¦q" fg"4222."hwpfc" ncu"dcugu"czkqn„ikecu" g"kpuvkvwekqpcngu"
rctc"rtqhwpfk¦ct"nc" fgoqetcekc"gp"Xgpg¦wgnc." cn"eqorngvct"ncu" vtcfkekqpcngu"hqtocu"g" kpuvcp/
ekcu"tgrtgugpvcvkxcu"fg"nqu"ukuvgocu"fgoqetƒvkequ"eqpvgorqtƒpgqu."eqp"pqxgfququ"{"ghgevkxqu"
LWTKURTWFGPEKC"
"
547
ogecpkuoqu"{" ogfkqu"fg" rctvkekrcek„p"c" vtcxfiu" fg"nqu" ewcngu" ncu"ekwfcfcpcu"{" nqu" ekwfcfcpqu"
rwgfgp."gp"nqu" fkuvkpvqu"pkxgngu" rqnvkeq/vgttkvqtkcngu." ugt"rtqvciqpkuvcu"gp"ncu"cevkxkfcfgu"guvcvc/
ngu"{" gp" nc"vqoc"fg" fgekukqpgu" rctc"n c"iguvk„p" fgn" kpvgtfiu" r¿dnkeq"{" gn" dkgp"eqo¿p." tqorkgpfq"
eqp"nc"Ðilusión de participaciónÑ"swg"ug"etg„" fwtcpvg"nc" xkigpekc"fg" nc"Eqpuvkvwek„p" fg"3;83." {"
swg" vcpvcu" xgegu" eqpurkt„" eqpvtc" nc" guvcdknkfcf" fgn" ukuvgoc" f goqetƒvkeq" gp" pwguvtq" rcu" *xgt."
Lwcp"Ectnqu"Tg{."El Futuro de la Democracia en Venezuela."WEX."Ectcecu."rr0"554"{"uu+0"
Fgp„vgug"eqoq" nc" fgoqetcekc"uqekcn" ug"guvcdngeg"gp" nc"Eqpuvkvwek„p" fg"Ygkoct."eqoq"
wp"ukuvgoc" fg" cuqekcek„p" swg" rtqowgxg" nc" tgkxkpfkecek„p" kiwcnkvctkc"fg" nqu" fgtgejqu" fg" ncu"
encugu" ogpqu" hcxqtgekfcu." ukgpfq" swg." gp" guvc" fgoqetcekc." nqu" ogecpkuoqu" fg" nc" fgekuk„p"
rqnvkec"{"nc"iguvk„p"fg"vqfc"nc"kpuvkvwekqpcnkfcf"fgn"Guvcfq"guvƒp"kphnwkfqu"rqt"nc"rctvkekrcek„p"
cevkxc"fg" ncu"cuqekcfcu"{" nqu"cuqekcfqu."pq" u„nq"gp" hqtoc" kpfktgevc"q" tgrtgugpvcvkxc." ukpq"gp"
hqtoc"fg" eqiguvk„p0" Gp" gn" ukuvgoc" fg" nc" fgoqetcekc" uqekcn" ncu" tgncekqpgu" fg" rqfgt" gpvtg" gn"
Guvcfq"{"ncu"ekw fcfcpcu"{"nqu"ekwfcfcpqu"uqp"q" vtcvcp"fg"ugt"rctkvctkcu=" gu"wp"ukuvgoc"rctvkek/
rcvkxq"fg"owvwc"tgurqpucdknkfcf"{."rqt"gpfg."fg"owvwc"gzkikdknkfcf0"
Fg"guvg" oqfq."eqoq" dkgp"nq" cenctc"nc" Gzrqukek„p"fg" Oqvkxqu"fg" nc"Eqpuvkvwek„p." gn"tfi/
ikogp" eqpuvkvwekqpcn" xkigpvg" tgurqpfg" c" wpc" ugpvkfc" curktcek„p" fg" rwgdnq" qticpk¦cfq" swg"
rwipc"rqt"ecodkct"nc" pgicvkxc"ewnvwtc"rqnvkec"igpgtcfc"rqt"ffiecfcu"fg" wp"Guvcfq"egpvtcnk¦c/
fq"fg"rctvkfqu"swg" ogfkcvk¦„"gn"fgucttqnnq" fg"nqu"xcnqtgu" fgoqetƒvkequ."c"vtcxfiu"fg"nc"rctvkek/
rcek„p"ekwfcfcpc"swg"{c"pq"ug"nkokvc"c" rtqeguqu"gngevqtcngu."rwgu"ug"tgeqpqeg"nc"pgegukfcf"fg"
nc"kpvgtxgpek„p"fgn"rwgdnq"gp"nqu"rtqeguqu" fg"hqtocek„p."hqtowncek„p"{"glgewek„p"fg"rqnvkecu"
r¿dnkecu."eqoq" ogfkq" rctc" uwrgtct" nqu" ffihkekvu"fg" iqdgtpcdknkfcf" swg" jcp" chgevcfq"pwguvtq"
ukuvgoc"rqnvkeq"fgdkfq"c"nc"ectgpekc"fg"ctoqpc"gpvtg"gn"Guvcfq"{"nc"uqekgfcf0"
Gnnq"kpfkec" swg"gn" oqfgnq" fgoqetƒvkeq"gngevkxq." rctvkekrcvkxq" {"rtqvci„pkeq" kpuvcwtcfq"
gp"Xgpg¦wgnc"c" rctvkt"fg"nc"gpvtcfc"gp"xkigpekc"fg" nc"Eqpuvkvwek„p"fg" 3;;;."eqpekdg"c" nc"igu/
vk„p"r¿dnkec." nc"rtgugtxcek„p" {"hqogpvq" fgn"dkgp" eqo¿p"eqoq" wp"rtqeguq" gp"gn" ewcn"ug" guvc/
dngeg"wpc"eqowpkecek„p"rgtocpgpvg" gpvtg"iqdgtpcpvgu"{"ekwfcfcpqu."gpvtg"nqu"tgrtgugpvcpvgu"
{"uwu"tgrtgugpvcfqu."nq"ewcn" kornkec"wpc" oqfkhkecek„p"tcfkecn." c"ucdgt." fg"tc¦."gp" nc"qtkgpvc/
ek„p"fg" ncu" tgncekqpgu" gpvtg"gn" Guvcfq" {" nc"uqekgfcf."gp" nc" swg"ug"fgxwgnxg"c"guvc"¿nvkoc"uw"
ngivkoq"g"kppgicdng"rtqvciqpkuoq."c"vtcxfiu"fgn"glgtekekq"fg"uwu"fgtgejqu" rqnvkequ"hwpfcogp/
vcngu."gpwpekcfqu"gp"gn"Ecrvwnq"KX"fgn"Vvwnq"KKK"fg"nc"Pqtoc"Uwrtgoc0"
Fkejq"rtqeguq" fg"rtqhwpfk¦cek„p" fg" nc"ewnvwtc" fgoqetƒvkec"fgn" rwgdnq" xgpg¦qncpq."xc"
rtqeguq"eqpuvkvw{gpvg"{" Eqpuvkvwek„p."ug"xg"cfgoƒu"tghqt¦cfq"gp"uwu" rtqr„ukvqu"rqt"gn" octeq"
lwtfkeq" kpvgtpcekqpcn." uwuetkvq" {" tcvkhkecfq" rqt" nc" Tgr¿dnkec" Dqnkxctkcpc" fg" Xgpg¦wgnc." gp"
ocvgtkc" fg" fgtgejqu" jwocpqu." ukgpfq" glgornq" fg" gnnq" nq" fkurwguvq" gp" gn" ctvewnq" 43" fg" nc"
Fgenctcek„p"Wpkxgtucn" fg" Fgtgejqu"Jwocpqu." kpvgitcpvg" fgn"nncocfq" dnqswg" fg"nc" eqpuvkvw/
ekqpcnkfcf"fg"cewgtfq"eqp"gn"ctvewnq"45"fgn"Vgzvq"Hwpfcogpvcn0"
Fg"vcn" ocpgtc"swg" gn"ectƒevgt" rctvkekrcvkxq" fg"nc" fgoqetcekc"gp" Xgpg¦wgnc"gp" nqu" fkhg/
tgpvgu"ƒodkvqu"fg" nc"cevkxkfcf"r¿dnkec"vkgpfg"rtqitgukxcogpvg"c"nc" eqpuqnkfcek„p"fg"nqu" xcnq/
tgu"fgoqetƒvkequ"{"c"nc"nkdgtvcf"{"nc"uqnkfctkfcf"gp"nqu"fkuvkpvqu"pkxgngu"rqnvkeq/vgttkvqtkcngu"
gp"swg"ug"fkuvtkdw{g"gn"Rqfgt" R¿dnkeq"c"nq"nctiq"{"cpejq"fg"nc"Tgr¿dnkec."{"rqt"gnnq" okuoq."uk"
dkgp"nc"fgoqetcekc"tgrtgugpvcvkxc"gu" nc"dcug"fgn"Guvcfq"fg"fgtgejq"{"fg"nqu"tgiogpgu"eqpuvk/
vwekqpcngu." fiuvc" ug" tghwgt¦c" {" rtqhwpfk¦c" ¿pkecogpvg" eqp" nc" rctvkekrcek„p" {" rtqvciqpkuoq"
rgtocpgpvg."fivkeq"{"tgurqpucdng"fg"nc"ekwfcfcpc0"
Oƒu"cnnƒ"fgn"guhwgt¦q" rqt"fghkpkt"nc"fgoqetcekc." guvc"kpuvkvwek„p"pq"ug" gpvkgpfg"eqp"eqp/
egrvqu"rwtcogpvg"vg„tkequ0"Nc"fgoqetcekc"gu"wp"ukuvgoc"fg"cuqekcek„p"rqnvkec"fgn"Guvcfq"eqp"
uwu"ekwfcfcpqu."swg" vkgpg"rqt" hkpcnkfcf"nqitct"wp" guvcfq"fg" dkgpguvct"igpgtcn0"Gp" nqu"Guvcfqu"
eqpuvkvwekqpcngu."guvg"rcevq" fguetkdg" nc" hqtoc" fg" iqdkgtpq" swg" ncu"uqek gfcfgu"jcp"fgekfkfq"
rctc"u."oqfgncpfq"uwu"rtqrkqu" eqpvgpkfqu"{" cnecpegu"c" rctvkt"fg" ncu"ektewpuvcpekcu" rqnvkecu."
uqekcngu" {" geqp„okecu" rtgxcngekgpvgu." cu" eqoq" fg" nqu" hcevqtgu" jkuv„tkequ." vtcfkekqpcngu" {"
ewnvwtcngu0"
Get this document and AI-powered insights with a free trial of vLex and Vincent AI
Get Started for FreeUnlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations