Por qué la Ley de Amnistía es una derogación de la Constitución española y una suplantación anti democrática del poder constituyente
| Author | José María Pernas Alonso |
| Position | octor en Derecho, Gobierno y Políticas Públicas Universidad Autónoma de Madrid |
| Pages | 9-49 |
"
Ctvewnqu"
Por qué la Ley de Amnistía es una derogación de la
Constitución española y una suplantación
anti democrática del poder constituyente
Lqufi"Octc"Rgtpcu"Cnqpuq"
Doctor en Derecho, Gobierno y Políticas Públicas Universidad Autónoma de Madrid.
Profesor derecho constitucional Universidad San Pablo-CEU
“¡Pero yo os digo que la libertad no significa aprovecharse de las
leyes con intención de destruirlas! No es la libertad la que permite que el
caballo de Troya sea metido dentro de nuestras murallas y que los que vi-
ven dentro sean oídos con el pretexto de la tolerancia. (...) No puede mon-
tar en dos caballos al mismo tiempo: no puede vivir en la legalidad y a la
vez conspirar”. Marco Tulio Cicerón, Preámbulo del segundo discurso
contra Catilina, citado en “La columna de hierro”.
Taylor Caldwell (2017) Embolsillo, 2ª edición, pp. 733 y 734
TguwogpLa aprobación de una Ley de Amnistía que valide las conductas reali-
zadas tras la declaración de independencia de Cataluña de 1 de octubre de 2017,
conllevaría una derogación de la Constitución por parte de un poder derivado (el
legislativo), al afectar a elementos clave de la misma, desconociendo el poder
constituyente y además incurriendo en una vulneración de los valores de Estado de
derecho, igualdad y democracia del artículo 2 del Tratado de la UE, lo que provo-
caría, además de posible responsabilidad administrativa para los poderes del Es-
tado y un vaciamiento de su soberanía, una vuelta al Estado absoluto o inclusive a
un Estado de naturaleza previo."
Rcncdtcu"EncxgAmnistía, Constitución, poder constituyente, democracia, igual-
dad, poder judicial."
CduvtcevThe approval of an Amnesty Law which validates the activities devel-
oped by Catalonian regional authorities from the declaration of independence of
1st of October 2023, leads to a derogation of the Spanish Constitution of 1978
through a delegate power (the legislative power), affecting key elements of the
Constitution, supplanting the constitutional power of the Spanish People and com-
mitting a violation of the values stated in article 2 of the Treaty of the European
Union as rule of law, equality under the law and democracy, which will produce
administrative responsibility of Spanish Public Administrations and an emptying of
the Spanish State sovereignty, causing a return of the Absolut State or even the
State of Nature."
Mg{" yqtfuAmnesty, Constitution, constitutional power of the Spanish people,
democracy, equality, judicial power."
TGXKUVC"FG"FGTGEJQ"RòDNKEQ"Ṗ"3971398"/"4245"
"
32"
UWOCTKQ"
K0"" KPVTQFWEEKïP""
KK0"" FKHGTGPEKCU"GPVTG"WPC"NG["FG"COPKUVëC"FG"4245"SWG"CPWNG"NC"GZENW/
UKXKFCF"FG"LW¥ICT"FGN"RQFGT"LWFKEKCN"["NC"KIWCNFCF"CPVG"NC"NG["GP"
WP"GUVCFQ"FGOQETèVKEQ"HTGPVG"C"NC"COPKUVëC"QVQTICFC"RQT"NC"NG["
FG"3;99"RTGXKC"C"NC"EQPUVKVWEKïP"FG"3;9:""
KKK0"" NC"RTQRQUKEKïP"FG"NG["FG"COPKUVëC"RTGUGPVCFC"GN"35"FG"PQXKGODTG"
FG"4245"CPVG"NC"OGUC"FGN"EQPITGUQ""
30"La exposición de Motivos de la proposición de ley de amnistía cita la STC 147/1986, ¿se
puede aplicar esa sentencia a este caso?"40"½Si se aprueba la ley de amnistía puede venir un
partido y derogarla en el futuroA"""
KX0"" FGTQICEKïP"FG"NC"EQPUVKVWEKïP"SWG"UG"RTQFWEKTëC"EQP"WPC"NG["FG"
COPKUVëC""
de la arbitrariedad, jerarquía normativa y seguridad jurídica0"60"Vulneración del principio
informe de Letrados de las Cortes de 2021 ya confirmó la inconstitucionalidad de una am-
nistía."90"Posible vulneración de la Ley 19/2013 de Transparencia, Acceso a la Información
Pública y Buen Gobierno, y de las Leyes 50/1997 y 39/2015 al estar el Gobierno redactan-
do un proyecto de ley en negociaciones con grupos parlamentarios sin dar trámite de con-
sulta pública ni publicar el texto objeto de negociación0"
X0"" WPC"NG["FG"COPKUVëC"UGTëC"EQPVTCTKC"CN"CTVëEWNQ"4"FGN"VTCVCFQ"FG"
NC"WPKïP"GWTQRGC"EQOQ"UG"FGTKXC"FG"LWTKURTWFGPEKC"TGKVGTCFC"FGN"
VTKDWPCN"FG"LWUVKEKC"FG"NC"WG"
XK0"" GP"VQFQ"ECUQ."GN"EQPITGUQ"FG"NQU"FKRWVCFQU"FGDGTëC"VTCOKVCT"NC"
RTQRQUKEKïP" FG" NG[" FG" COPKUVëC" EQOQ" WP" RTQ[GEVQ" FG" TGHQTOC"
EQPUVKVWEKQPCN" SWG" GZKIG" OC[QTëC" FG" 415" FGN" EQPITGUQ" [" FGN" UG/
PCFQ"["EQPXQECVQTKC"FG"GNGEEKQPGU"C"EQTVGU"EQPUVKVW[GPVGU"
XKK0"" NC"NG["FG"COPKUVëC"UGTëC"CRNKECDNG"FGUFG"UW"CRTQDCEKïP"UKP"SWG"GN"
VTKDWPCN"EQPUVKVWEKQPCN"VGPIC"QDNKICVQTKCOGPVG"SWG"UWURGPFGT"
UWU"GHGEVQU"
XKKK0"" NC" NKDGTVCF" FGOQETèVKEC" RCUC" GP" RTKOGT" NWICT" RQT" GN" TGURGVQ" CN"
QTFGP"EQPUVKVWEKQPCN"["RQT"PQ"UWRNCPVCT"CN"RQFGT"EQPUVKVW[GPVG"
KZ0"" NC"COPKUVëC"KORNKEC."CFGOèU"FG"NC"FGTQICEKïP"FG"NC"EQPUVKVWEKïP"
RQT"WP"RQFGT"FGTKXCFQ"/GN"NGIKUNCVKXQ/."NC"SWKGDTC"FGN"QTFGP"Rò/
DNKEQ"["NC"XWGNVC"CN"GUVCFQ"CDUQNWVQ"["GP"EKGTVQ"ITCFQ."CN"GUVC/
FQ"FG"PCVWTCNG¥C"CPVGTKQT"CN"GUVCFQ"OQFGTPQ"
Z0"" NC"RTQRQUKEKïP"FG"NG["FG"COPKUVëC"RTQXQEC"SWG"GN"TG["VWXKGTC"EC/
RCEKFCF" FG" TGXQECT" UW" RTQRWGUVC" FG" KPXGUVKFWTC" RQT" OCPKHKGUVC"
KPEQPUVKVWEKQPCNKFCF"FGN"RTQITCOC"FG"IQDKGTPQ""
ZKK0"" EQPENWUKQPGU"*UR+ C"FGOQETCEKC"GURC¢QNC"FG"
WPC"NG["FG"COPKUVëC
K0"" KPVTQFWEEKïP"
Nc"copkuvc"swg"ug"rtgvgpfg"eqpegfgt"c"nqu"rqnvkequ"{"gorngcfqu"r¿dnkequ"fg"nc"Igpgtc/
nkvcv"fg"Ecvcnwp{c"swg"rqukdknkvctqp"wucpfq"hqpfqu"r¿dnkequ"nc"egngdtcek„p"gn"3"fg"qevwdtg"fg"
4239" fg" wp" tghgtfipfwo" fg" kpfgrgpfgpekc." uktxkfipfqug" fg" nc" rqnkec" cwvqp„okec." gu" nkvgtcn/
ogpvg"eqpegfgt"wpc"ÐcopgukcÑ"w"qnxkfq"fgn"Guvcfq."fg"hqtoc"swg"ug"fgenctc"swg"gucu"eqpfwe/
vcu"hwgtqp"xƒnkfcu"{"swg"nc"ncdqt"fgn"rqfgt"ngikuncvkxq"/crnkecpfq"gn"ctv0"377"fg"nc"Eqpuvkvwek„p"
GUVWFKQU"
"
33
gurc‚qnc"*EG+"/."fgn"rqfgt"lwfkekcn"/korwnucpfq"nc"kpxguvkicek„p"{"lw¦icpfq"{"fkevcpfq"ugp/
vgpekcu"uqdtg"gucu"eqpfwevcu/."{"fgn"rqfgt"glgewvkxq"- glgewvcpfq"nqu"cwvqu"{"ugpvgpekcu"lwfk/
ekcngu"/."hwg"pwnc"{"rqt"vcpvq"kngivkoc."fg"oqfq"swg"vtcu"nc"rtqrkc"Ng{"fg"copkuvc"fkejcu"
eqpfwevcu"rqftcp"xqnxgtug"c"eqogvgt"cn"ectgegt"nqu"rqfgtgu"fgn"Guvcfq"fg"ngikvkokfcf"rctc"
rgtugiwktncu"*c"ucnxq"fg"swg"gn"VE"fgenctg"eqp"nc"wtigpekc"pgeguctkc"nc"kpeqpuvkvwekqpcnkfcf"
fg"fkejc"Ng{"fg"Copkuvc."cwpswg"eqoq"gzrnkectfi."uqnq"gn"tgewtuq"fg"kpeqpuvkvwekqpcnkfcf"fgn"
rtqrkq"Iqdkgtpq"vgpftc"ectƒevgt"uwurgpukxq"fg"nc"Ng{+0""
Guvc"Ng{"fg"Copkuvc"vgpftc"guqu"ghgevqu."rqtswg"kornkectc"cpwnct"nc"ncdqt"fgn"rqfgt"
lwfkekcn"{"ngicnk¦ct"ncu"eqpfwevcu"tgcnk¦cfcu="ktc"rqt"vcpvq"owejq"oƒu"cnnƒ"fg"wp"kpfwnvq"kpfk/
xkfwcn"*swg"{c"jcp"ukfq"eqpegfkfqu"c"xctkqu"rqnvkequ"kpfgrgpfgpvkuvcu+."rqt"ewcpvq"gn"kpfwnvq"
gu"wp"ogtq"rgtf„p"c"nc"rgpc"korwguvc."rgtq"pq"ngicnk¦c"nc"eqpfwevc"{"rqt"vcpvq"gn"rgtfqpcfq"
pq"rwgfg"xqnxgt"c"eqogvgtnc"rqtswg"nc"eqpfwevc"ukiwg"ukgpfq"cpvklwtfkec0"Nc"copkuvc"kornk/
ec"fgenctct"swg"ncu"eqpfwevcu"hwgtqp"xƒnkfcu"{"swg"rqt"vcpvq"nc"ncdqt"fgn"rqfgt"lwfkekcn"hwg"
gtt„pgc"{"fkejq"rqfgt"lwfkekcn"pq"ncu"rwgfg"xqnxgt"c"rgtugiwkt0"
Vtcu" nc" rtgugpvcek„p" gn" 35" fg" pqxkgodtg" fg" 4245" cpvg" nc" Oguc" fgn" Eqpitguq" fg" nqu"
Fkrwvcfqu"fg"nc"Rtqrqukek„p"fg"Ng{"fg"Copkuvc."{"nc"kpxguvkfwtc"fgn"ecpfkfcvq"*38"fg"pq/
xkgodtg+" swg" eqpvgpc" gp" uw" rtqitcoc" fg" iqdkgtpq" fkejc" Copkuvc." gu" pgeguctkq" tgcnk¦ct"
cniwpcu"tghngzkqpgu"uqdtg"uk"guvcu"cevwcekqpgu"fgn"ngikuncvkxq"kornkecp"wp"xcekcokgpvq"fg"nc"
Eqpuvkvwek„p"fg"3;9:"rqt"wp"rqfgt"fgtkxcfq."ukp"jcdgt"eqpuwnvcfq"rqt"vcpvq"cn"rqfgt"eqpuvk/
vw{gpvg"*gn"rwgdnq"gurc‚qn+."{"uwu"eqpugewgpekc"rctc"nc"ngikvkocek„p"fgoqetƒvkec"fg"pwguvtcu"
kpuvkvwekqpgu0""
Cfgoƒu"fg"fgoquvtct"nc"kpeqpuvkvwekqpcnkfcf"fg"wpc"Ng{"fg"Copkuvc"swg"ug"rwgfc"fke/
vct"gp"gn"c‚q"4245."cnwfktgoqu"c"swg"fkejc"Ng{"fg"Copkuvc"ug"guvƒ"pgiqekcpfq"rqt"gn"Iq/
dkgtpq"{"itwrqu"rctncogpvctkqu"swg"nq"crq{cp"ukp"pkpiwpc"vtcpurctgpekc."c"rguct"fg"ncu"gzk/
igpekcu" fg" nc" Ng{" 3;14235." fg" Vtcpurctgpekc." Dwgp" Iqdkgtpq" {" Ceeguq" c" nc" Kphqtocek„p"
R¿dnkeq."Ng{"7213;;9."fgn"Iqdkgtpq"{"Ng{"5;14237."fg"Rtqegfkokgpvq"Cfokpkuvtcvkxq"Eqo¿p"
fg"ncu"Cfokpkuvtcekqpgu"R¿dnkecu0"
Cpvgu"fg"cpcnk¦ct"nc"copkuvc"dclq"nc"„rvkec"fgn"fgtgejq"r¿dnkeq"gurc‚qn"{"fg"nc"WG"{"fg"
nc" lwtkurtwfgpekc" fgn" Vtkdwpcn" Eqpuvkvwekqpcn" *VE+" {" fgn" Vtkdwpcn" fg" Lwuvkekc" fg" nc" WG"
*VLWG+.""gu"korqtvcpvg"rtgxkcogpvg"cpcnk¦ct"rqt"swfi"pq"rwgfg"corctctug"wpc"Ng{"fg"Copku/
vc"gp"gn"c‚q"4245"*rctc"eqpfwevcu"lw¦icfcu"rqt"wp"rqfgt"lwfkekcn"gocpcfq"fg"wpc"Eqpuvkvw/
ek„p"fgoqetƒvkec+."gp"nc"Copkuvc"qvqticfc"gp"3;99"rqt"ncu"Eqtvgu"Eqpuvkvw{gpvgu"swg"gncdq/
tcdcp"nc"Eqpuvkvwek„p"fg"3;9:."rctc"ncu"eqpfwevcu"rtqfwekfcu"gp"wp"tfiikogp"pq"fgoqetƒvkeq0"
Eqoq"xgtgoqu"nc"copkuvc"kornkec."cfgoƒu"fg"wp"kpewornkokgpvq"fg"rtgegrvqu"gugpekc/
ngu" fg" nc" Eqpuvkvwek„p" {" fg" nqu" xcnqtgu" fg" Guvcfq" fg" Fgtgejq." kiwcnfcf" {" fgoqetcekc" fgn"
ctvewnq"4"fgn"Vtcvcfq"fg"nc"WG."wpc"fgungikvkocek„p"fg"nqu"rqfgtgu"fgn"Guvcfq."swg"igpgtctc"
wpc"tgurqpucdknkfcf"rcvtkoqpkcn"fgn"Guvcfq."cfgoƒu"fg"xcekct"fg"eqpvgpkfq"gn"Guvcfq"gurc‚qn."
jwtvƒpfqng"uw"uqdgtcpc"{"rtqxqecpfq"wp"guvcfq"fg"pcvwtcng¦c"rtg/Guvcfq"oqfgtpq"fqpfg"nqu"
rqfgtgu" r¿dnkequ" ectgegtcp" fg" ngikvkokfcf" rctc" rgtugiwkt" cevwcekqpgu" kpeqpuvkvwekqpcngu"{"
rqt"vcpvq"rgtfgtcp"nc"ecrcekfcf"fg"igpgtct"qdgfkgpekc"gpvtg"nqu"ekwfcfcpqu0""
Rqt"qvtq"ncfq."vgpkgpfq"gp"ewgpvc"swg."eqoq"cpcnk¦ctgoqu."nqu"tgewtuqu"q"ewguvkqpgu"fg"
kpeqpuvkvwekqpcnkfcf"swg"ug"kpvgtrqpicp"cpvg"wpc"Ng{"fg"Copkuvc"pq"kornkecp"wpc"uwurgp/
uk„p"fg"uwu"ghgevqu"*rgtokvkgpfq"rqt"vcpvq"nc"nkdgtvcf"fg"ekgpvqu"fg"ugpvgpekcfqu"q"gpecwucfqu"
{"nc"cwugpekc"fg"rciq"fg"fgegpcu"fg"oknnqpgu"fg"gwtqu"ocnxgtucfqu."nc"fgecgt"ewcnswkgt"og/
fkfc"ecwvgnct"cfqrvcfc+."{"fcfq"swg"uqnq"gn"tgewtuq"fgn"Iqdkgtpq"vkgpg"ghgevqu"uwurgpukxqu."ug"
cpcnk¦c"swfi"ecrcekfcf"vkgpg"gn"Tg{."vtcu"eqpqegt"swg"gn"rtqitcoc"fg"Iqdkgtpq"fgn"ecpfkfcvq"
kpenw{g"nc"rtqrqukek„p"fg"ng{"fg"copkuvc."rctc"tgxqect"gug"gpectiq"fg"kpxguvkfwtc"eqp"gn"hkp"
fg"ictcpvk¦ct"nc"rgtocpgpekc"fgn"Guvcfq"{"jcegt"ewornkt"nc"Eqpuvkvwek„p"eqoq"hwpekqpgu"fgn"
Tg{"kpenwkfcu"gp"nc"EG0"
Get this document and AI-powered insights with a free trial of vLex and Vincent AI
Get Started for FreeUnlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations